<img src="https://www.instinct-agilebusiness.com/806375.png" style="display:none;">

How to Choose an EHR System: Selection and Planning Tips

Financial Wellness Healthcare Technology
How to Choose the Right EHR for Your Healthcare Organization | Patagonia Health

Key Takeaways

  • Build a selection team that represents every part of your organization, from clinical staff to billing, and keep them involved from the needs assessment through the demos.
  • Choose an EHR built for your specialty. A general-purpose system can force staff into workarounds for the life of your contract.
  • Compare vendors on total cost of ownership over the full contract, not the base price. Implementation, interfaces, add-on modules, and volume-based fees add up.
  • Ask what support looks like during implementation and after go-live, and confirm the vendor has a live interface to your state’s systems, not just the ability to build one.
  • Check references from organizations like yours and review contract terms like data ownership and itemized pricing before you sign.

Why Strategic EHR Planning Matters

Implementing an Electronic Health Record (EHR) is one of the most important steps a healthcare organization can take. Whether you're moving from paper records or another EHR vendor, a structured approach to EHR system selection helps you avoid costly mistakes, minimize disruption, and choose a system that supports patient care.

The sections below walk through how to know it’s time for a change, the two main types of EHR systems, and how to select an EHR system step by step, so you can find one that fits both your clinical workflows and your regulatory needs.

How Do I Know When It’s Time to Switch EHR Vendors?

If you and your staff feel like your EHR creates more problems than it solves, it may be time to consider a new system. Start by asking your team a few questions. Do they rely on workarounds to get their work done? Is it hard to share data with labs and registries? For more questions to help you decide, check out our blog, How to Know When It’s Time to Transition to a New EHR. 

Modular vs. All-in-One EHR Systems 

Most EHRs fall into one of two designs: a modular setup that combines tools from several vendors, or an all-in-one system from a single vendor. The right fit depends on how much customization you need, what you can spend, and how much IT support you have in-house. 

 

Modular EHR

All-in-One EHR

Setup

Built from multiple vendors' tools

One vendor for EHR, Practice Management, and Billing

Flexibility

High; you can pick a specialized tool for each need

Configurable, with less need to build from scratch

Technical demand

Requires in-house IT to manage integrations

Vendor handles integration, updates, and security

Interoperability

Depends on how well the pieces connect

Built to work together out of the box

Long-term cost

Can rise as integrations grow and break

More predictable under a single subscription

Customization

Extensive

Historically limited, but many cloud-based systems now offer local configuration that narrows the gap

Best fit for

Large organizations with strong internal IT and highly specialized needs

Teams that want to spend time on care, not system management

 

Many all-in-one systems today are cloud-based. Cloud-based EHRs deliver a balance of personalization, cost efficiency, and compliance, making them a practical option for many public and behavioral health organizations.

Unlike on-premises systems, which require organizations to host and maintain the software on their own servers, cloud-based EHRs run on the vendor's infrastructure, so you get lower up-front costs and leave the upkeep to your vendor.

EHR Selection Criteria: Key Factors to Evaluate

When selecting an EHR system, evaluate EHR software in the following areas to find the best fit for your needs.

Certifications and Security Reviews

EHR certification programs help healthcare organizations verify they are investing in secure Electronic Health Record (EHR) solutions. Key certifications to look for include:

  • ONC Health IT Certification: Confirms that an ONC-Authorized Certification Body has tested the EHR against federal standards for functionality, interoperability, and security. Ask whether the system is certified to the 21st Century Cures Act Update criteria, which added requirements like standardized APIs and electronic health information export.
  • HL7 2.5.1: The messaging standard most state immunization registries and public health agencies use for electronic reporting. Ask each vendor to confirm it can send and receive HL7 2.5.1 messages with your state’s systems.

Some federal programs, like Medicare’s Promoting Interoperability program, require certified EHR technology. When you evaluate EHR solutions, look up each vendor on the Certified Health IT Product List (CHPL) to confirm its certification is current.

Usability and Configurability

An EHR interface that is easy to use makes it faster for staff to find and update patient information. Look for an interface that fits your workflow and is easy to learn. During demos, have staff try a common task themselves, like documenting a visit, and note how many steps it takes. Find out whether staff can adjust things like forms, templates, and workflows themselves, or whether every change requires IT involvement or the vendor to write custom code; that difference affects both your costs and how quickly you can respond to new needs.

Total Cost of Ownership

Every EHR vendor prices its software differently. Some charge per provider, others per user or per module. When you compare vendors on cost and value, look past the price of the software itself, and make sure each contract spells out what you'll pay for, including:

  • Implementation, data migration, and training
  • Support after go-live, and whether premium support costs extra
  • Modules and services outside the base subscription, like Telehealth, Patient Portal, or e-prescribing
  • Custom work for anything the system doesn't do out of the box
  • Interfaces with labs and state immunization registries, which often carry a setup fee plus annual maintenance
  • Volume-based fees, such as charges per claim, appointment reminder, or clearinghouse transaction, or a percentage of your collections

To compare vendors fairly, ask each one for the total cost of ownership: everything you'll pay over the length of the contract, based on your staff and programs.

If one option is priced well below the rest, look closely at what’s driving that number down. Lower-cost vendors often provide less support during implementation and may use offshore teams to handle support tickets. Third-party review sites like Software Advice rate vendors on “Value for money” and “Customer support,” so check both scores before you decide.

For a full breakdown of pricing models and fees, read How Much Does an EHR Cost? A Guide to EHR Pricing and How to Compare Vendors.

Vendor Training, Before and After Implementation

Adequate and effective EHR training for staff members is essential. Training quality is closely tied to how staff feel about their EHR. In KLAS Arch Collaborative research, clinicians who reported poor training were far more likely to be unsatisfied with their EHR. A combination of on-site training and flexible, virtual training times will maximize success.

Evaluate the training your vendor provides in the short and long term. Ask how long you’ll work with a dedicated trainer during implementation, and whether the vendor offers an on-demand training library, like Patagonia Health Academy, so team members who join after go-live can get trained without relying entirely on your existing staff.

Ongoing Support after Go-Live

Ask each vendor what support looks like during implementation and after go-live. For implementation, find out whether the vendor configures the system for you or leaves most of the setup to your staff, and how long you’ll work with a dedicated trainer before you’re handed off to general support.

To judge ongoing support after go-live, ask what hours it’s available and how quickly tickets are answered and resolved. Talking to references from organizations like yours will tell you more about a vendor’s customer support than a demo will.

Support matters more than many teams expect. For health departments, especially, state reporting requirements change often, and a new grant can bring in new programs. Solid support can be the difference between meeting new requirements quickly and falling behind.

Vendor Stability and Ownership

The EHR market has seen a lot of consolidation, with smaller vendors being bought out and folded into larger companies. After an acquisition, a product can be retired, merged into another platform, or given less attention, and support teams and pricing can change.

Before you sign, ask who owns the company, how long it has served organizations like yours, and what happens to your contract if the company is acquired. Strong data ownership and transfer terms in your contract protect you if the vendor changes hands.

 

 

Must-Have EHR Features for Your Programs

Start by listing your must-have features based on the services you provide, the reporting you’re responsible for, and the outside systems you share data with, such as state registries or a Health Information Exchange (HIE). Specialties like public and behavioral health need different things from an EHR, so here’s what to look for in each.

What Does a Public Health EHR Need?

Health departments have operational requirements that general-purpose systems often miss. When evaluating options for a local health department (LHD), look for:

  • Immunization workflows built for clinic and field settings, with two-way exchange with your state immunization information system (IIS), so the registry updates at the point of care.
  • Reporting and compliance support for federal and state requirements, including electronic lab reporting (ELR) for communicable diseases.
  • Integrated billing configured for sliding fee scale programs.
  • Caseload management and care coordination, including referral orders, plus encounter note templates for services like immunization clinics, family planning, and communicable disease.
  • Integrations. Ask whether the vendor has a live, working interface to your state's systems, specifically, not whether the system supports that kind of interface in general. Having to connect interfaces can majorly impact your implementation timeline.

For a closer look at each of these functionalities, see our guide to the top six EHR functionalities for public health.

What Does a Behavioral Health EHR Need?

Behavioral health agencies, clinics, and mental health organizations need a different feature set than primary care. When a system doesn't match how clinicians work, documentation quality and billing accuracy both slip. Look for:

  • Clinical documentation built for behavioral health, with customizable progress note templates for therapy, case management, group sessions, and crisis services, plus a treatment planner with goal tracking and standardized assessments that can be scored and tracked in the system.
  • Compliance and reporting support for 42 CFR Part 2 and HIPAA, including the 2024 Part 2 final rule, role-based access, audit logging, and golden thread documentation, meaning each progress note ties back to the client’s assessment and treatment plan goals, so records hold up under audit.
  • Integrated billing and revenue cycle management configured for Medicaid, managed care organization (MCO) billing, and value-based payment models.
  • Caseload management and alerts that flag overdue documentation, expiring authorizations, and upcoming plan reviews, with dashboards that give supervisors a live view of caseloads.
  • Integrations with the systems you depend on, such as your state Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP), electronic prescribing of controlled substances (EPCS), and Medicaid and managed care portals. Ask whether the interface already runs in your state, and if you can speak to an organization currently using it.

For a closer look at each of these functionalities, see our guide to the top six EHR functionalities for behavioral health.

AdobeStock_2002261065

How to Select an EHR System in 9 Steps

1. Build Your EHR Selection Team

The person leading implementation for your organization (your “EHR champion”) should have the authority to make decisions and dedicated time to manage the project. Build a small selection team around them that represents every part of your organization, from clinical staff to billing, and keep them involved from start to finish. Each group knows its own workflows best, and software that works well for one area can force workarounds in another.

2. Conduct a Needs Assessment

Gather feedback from staff across your organization about what works and what doesn’t in your current process, whether it’s paper-based or digital. Turn that feedback into a list of must-have features that support your long-term goals. Be sure to include your state, federal, and grant reporting requirements, plus any interfaces you’ll need. Don’t just list what your current system does. Think about where your programs will be in five years and whether the system can scale with you.

3. Evaluate Financial Readiness

Before you talk to vendors, figure out where the funding will come from, whether that’s grants, your operating budget, or capital funds. Plan for more than the software itself. Training, data migration, workflow changes, and lost productivity during go-live all add to the cost. You won’t have exact numbers until vendors send quotes, but a rough range will help you narrow your options.

4. Contact Vendors or Issue an RFP

Health departments and other government agencies usually need to issue a Request for Proposal (RFP) to meet procurement rules for EHR software selection and purchase. An RFP details your clinical, financial, and technical requirements and invites vendors to explain how their solutions meet your needs.  For a list of questions to include in your RFP, see What to Look for in an EHR Vendor.  

If you don't need an RFP, contact vendors directly and ask for a quote based on your number of users, sites, and the modules you need.

Tip: Some health departments may be able to skip the RFP process by using a neighboring county’s existing EHR contract or by requesting sole source approval. Check your procurement rules first.

5. Demo and Score Each EHR Vendor

Check whether your RFP or procurement rules require a set number of demos, then invite the vendors whose proposals best match your requirements to demo their software. Invite staff from across your organization to attend, especially people who will use the system every day. Give every attendee a scorecard for their area, and have them rate each vendor from 1 to 5.

Give every vendor the same script of real workflows, like checking in a patient, documenting a visit, and submitting a claim, so you can compare them side by side. For the vendors you’re most interested in, you can schedule follow-up demos that focus on specific workflows, such as billing or clinical documentation.

6. Compare Total Cost of Ownership

Each vendor quotes differently, so comparing prices is harder than it looks. Ask for the total cost of ownership over the length of the contract, including training, interfaces, and per-transaction fees for things like claims and eligibility checks. For more, see our guide to EHR pricing.

7. Check References from Similar Organizations

Make sure the EHR works well for organizations like yours. Ask each vendor for three to five references from organizations of a similar size. Health departments should also ask for a complete list of LHDs using the software and choose which ones to contact themselves. If possible, visit a site that uses the software to see how it works day to day.

8. Review Contract Terms Before You Sign

Before you sign, make sure you understand what your contract says. Confirm that your organization owns its patient data and that the vendor will return your records in a standard format if you leave. Also check that pricing is itemized, including what changes at renewal, and that the vendor will sign a Business Associate Agreement (BAA).

9. Prepare for Implementation

Once the contract is signed, set your go-live date and lock in training dates. Implementation processes vary by vendor, but it always helps to keep all your project documents in one shared folder and hold regular updates so staff know what’s changing and when. For a full checklist, including contract terms to review, see our guide to a successful EHR implementation.

FAQs About How to Choose an EHR System

What Is the Difference Between an EMR and an EHR?

An EMR is a digital version of a patient’s paper chart, used within a single practice. An EHR pulls in data from multiple providers and is built to share it securely with labs, pharmacies, specialists, and other care settings. Many EHRs also include tools for care management and patient engagement. For more, see EMR vs EHR: Key Differences.

How Long Does a Full EHR Procurement and Implementation Process Take?

Planning and procurement typically span several months, sometimes as long as a year, depending on your organization’s readiness, vendor response time, and contract negotiation process.

How Do I Ensure My EHR Meets Privacy and Security Laws?

Choose a system certified under the ONC Health IT Certification Program, and confirm the vendor will sign a Business Associate Agreement (BAA). Ask how the system handles role-based access, audit logs, and data encryption, and, if you treat substance use disorders, how it supports 42 CFR Part 2 consent. The software alone won’t make you compliant, so build privacy training for all staff into your implementation and check for any state-specific requirements.

What Is the Biggest Cause of EHR Implementation Failure?

Common problems include choosing a system that doesn’t fit your workflows, along with gaps in training and workflow planning. Take your time choosing an EHR, and test it against your real workflows during demos. Engage your staff early, identify super users, and conduct thorough readiness and workflow assessments before go-live.

How Can Small or Resource-Limited Agencies Manage Costs?

Look into grants and consider starting with core modules and adding others later. You can also team up with neighboring health departments if your procurement rules allow it. In Kansas, several small county health departments used a CDC-funded grant to choose and implement an EHR together and pooled their training hours to cut costs.

What’s the Difference Between “Updates,” “Upgrades,” and “Add-Ons”?

  • Updates fix minor issues and maintain compliance.

  • Upgrades introduce major new features.

  • Add-ons are optional modules to enhance functionality.

When you compare vendors, ask which of these are included in your subscription and which cost extra.

The Future of EHR Success

EHR adoption is not a one-time project; it’s a continuous process of improvement. Following these steps when choosing an EHR system helps you find one that meets your organization’s needs today and adapts as technology and regulations change.

Patagonia Health’s cloud-based, ONC-certified EHR simplifies procurement, implementation, and interoperability for both public and behavioral health agencies. This empowers providers to focus on what matters most: improving community health outcomes.

logo-without_text

Patagonia Health is the preferred EHR, Practice Management, and Billing solution for public and behavioral health providers. We empower you with the tools you need to simplify admin work and transform care in your community.

Click here to set up a call with a member of our sales team.

Other Articles on This Topic

Vendor Approved vs. Rejected

What to Look for in an EHR Vendor: RFPs, Demos, and Red Flags

Hand holding a medication for medicated assisted treatment

How to Document Medication-Assisted Treatment in Your Behavioral Health EHR

Public health leader on computer using ehr

EHR Modernization for State and Metro Health Departments